The Commerce Department, in its preliminary finding over illegal subsidies, said solar panels imported from China would face a duty of 2.9% to 4.73%, smaller than what some had hoped for.
Workers assemble solar panels by hand on the factory floor of Chinese company Suntech in the eastern Chinese city of Wuxi. (Peter Parks, AFP/Getty Images / March 20, 2012)
March 20, 2012
Ratcheting up the battle over a vital energy industry, the U.S. Commerce Department decided to impose tariffs on solar panels imported from China after concluding that manufacturers there received illegal government subsidies.
The Commerce Department, in its preliminary finding over illegal subsidies, said solar panels imported from China — now dominating the U.S. market — would face a duty of 2.9% to 4.73%.
The tariff is considerably smaller than what some had hoped for but nonetheless marks another step by the Obama administration to get tougher on trade with China. It also highlights efforts aimed at supporting U.S jobs and a renewable energy future.
Additional tariffs could be imposed in mid-May when the Commerce Department is expected to determine whether China has been dumping the panels in the U.S. at below-cost prices.
Some American lawmakers and solar firms hailed the finding on illegal subsidies, saying the new tariffs will help create a more-level playing field for the domestic solar market, which has been growing rapidly despite the bankruptcy of some panel makers. The high-profile failure of solar equipment maker Solyndra of Fremont, Calif., was attributed in part to a sudden influx of low-cost Chinese panels.
The Commerce Department decision “is a signal that China’sunfair trade practices in the solar energy industry may soon be remedied,” said Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), who heads aSenate Finance subcommittee on international trade.
The senator recently released a report detailing the widening U.S. trade deficit with China on environmental goods such as solar panels.
Gordon Brinser, president of SolarWorld Industries America, which with six other U.S. firms filed the trade case with the Commerce Department, said the decision would help restore fair competition and advance the U.S. solar industry’s “reach for greater national energy, economic and environmental security.”
Experts, though, said the tariffs, which range from 2.9% to 4.73% to correspond to the amount of Chinese subsidies found, aren’t big enough to have a major effect on the market.
“This is a modest one that should be viewed as an indication that more is to come,” said Tom Soto, co-founder and managing partner of Craton Equity Partners, a Los Angeles clean-technology fund.
Although nobody knew how much in loans, land, tax breaks and other subsidies Chinese producers received from the government, the basic assumption had been that the total was large, at least in the double digits.
“This really for the first time sheds light on the amount of support they give to the solar industry,” said Rhone Resch, chief executive of the Solar Energy Industries Assn. Based on the Commerce Department’s findings, he said, the subsidies are “not very much.”
The tariffs brought statements akin to words of vindication from such Chinese firms as Suntech Power Holdings Co., the world’s largest solar panel maker, with headquarters in Wuxi, China.
On Wall Street, shares of Chinese solar panel makers soared, and there was a collective sigh of relief on the part of developers of solar panels in the U.S., who feared that large duties would undermine the surging growth in solar developments by sharply increasing global prices or triggering a trade war.
“I’m relieved the tariffs are as modest as they are,” said Tony Clifford, chief executive of Standard Solar, a solar projects developer and installer based in Rockville, Md. He said he buys a majority of his panels from Chinese makers.
But referring to the anti-dumping case, Clifford said: “We’re still waiting for the other shoe to drop.”
Commerce Department officials said they had notified their Chinese counterparts Tuesday of the preliminary decision on illegal subsidies. There was no immediate comment from Chinese officials, but in the past, some have bristled at the threat of duties imposed on green-technology manufacturers that Beijing sees as crucial for its economic security.
China controls about 50% of the U.S. market for solar panels. The Commerce Department said Chinese imports of solar panels totaled $3.1 billion last year, up from $640 million in 2009.
Experts said the U.S. remained the leader in solar cell technology, but China has made significant strides in boosting its exports of both solar cells and panels — and drawing U.S. companies such asApplied Materials to set up major solar research operations in China.